Mattenga's Pizzeria Callaghan

M. 2 weeks ago

I’ve tried multiple pizza locations, and the consistency is seriously impressive. They get the pizza right every single time, the perfect amount of cheese, the right amount of sauce, and cooked to perfection. It’s the kind of pizza where you finish a slice and immediately want another one. This has officially become my new pizza spot and, in my opinion, the best pizza in the area. The wings are top notch too. Compared to so many other pizza places, the quality really stands out. The pizza is definitely the star, but the wings were excellent, and the two desserts I tried were absolutely delicious as well. Everything tasted fresh and high quality. The service deserves just as much credit. Everyone was friendly, attentive, and made sure the order was exactly right. They even showed me the pizza before handing it over to make sure I was happy with it and that everything was nice and hot. You can tell these guys work hard and actually care about what they’re serving. It honestly feels like they put love into their food, and it shows. This is the kind of pizza I could eat every day and still keep coming back for more. Highly recommend Mattenga’s Pizzeria!

Kellie Stancliff a month ago

I used the mobile order. Food was ready on time. Cashier checked my oder as I picked up to make sure all was correct. I appreciate that little step. Pizza tastes great! Will order again!

Renee Richmond 5 months ago

Y'all, this place is epic! I absolutely loved the food, and the employees were so helpful. The veggies on my pizza looked like they were straight from a produce department. Run and try it!

Cecilia Fuentes 9 months ago

This was our first time trying this place. We ordered a 16” molto meat and a 10” supreme pizza. I have to say the pizza crust tasted so fresh and delicious!. It was thin on bottom and fluffy towards the outside. It had just the right amount of fresh toppings. Definitely coming back again. Gotta try their buffet Mon-Fri, 11-2pm.

GiGi’s List a year ago

I recently ordered a 10-inch veggie pizza for takeout from Mattenga's Pizza, and I have to say, it was a pretty solid experience. I placed the order online, and after about 15 minutes, I drove over to pick it up. When I got there, the pizza was already ready and waiting for me, which is always a plus. The restaurant wasn't very busy at the time, but it was after 8:00 PM. There were a few people dining in, but it was still a relaxed environment. Once I got home, I couldn't resist snapping a picture of the pizza before digging in. The first thing I noticed when I took my first bite was the crust, it was perfectly crispy, which I really appreciated. It had a nice texture that balanced well with the soft, well-cooked veggies, tomato sauce, and cheese. Everything was cooked just right, and the flavor was on point, not too greasy, with the right amount of seasoning. Another thing I noticed while I was at the restaurant was that they have a pizza buffet during lunch hours. That could definitely be worth checking out next time I’m in the mood for a variety of slices. I was really happy with the pizza. It was simple but delicious, and I’ll definitely be back to give them another try, ma